Sterling vs edelrid rope reddit. I also have double ropes.

Sterling vs edelrid rope reddit. All I've been told is dry ropes are a waste of money (as I really don't do anything that requires the dry treatment) and that I don't need a bi-pattern rope. 8mm or the Edelrid Eagle Pro Light 9. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. 2: Best Half Ropes. I've heard great things about all of them but I'm still not sure which one I want. The Sterling rope just felt infinitely better--it handled way more smoothly, and it actually felt thinner than the kinky Mammut rope. 9 mm PowerCord is ultra-high strength in a small package. 5mm 60m ropes (pro: lightest triple rated, cons: heavier half/twin). Specific decent ropes that are easy to find cheap any day of the week: Sterling Kosmos, Edelrid Boa. I was looking at the edelrid starling protect pro dry 8. 5. Bi-color is game changing for multiple rappels, pitches longer than 35m, and various unexpected situations (understand that's not something you do much of now). I also have double ropes. 5 in the same trip. 80m Workhorse-rope new vs. The home of Climbing on reddit. so its longevity was shortened do to the dirt and abrasive rock. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Just watched the newest "hardiseasy" video, about ropes being cut and the new Mammut "core protect" technology. Edelrid and Mammut ropes have been good in my experience, didn't like any of the Beal or Maxims I've climbed on. If you look at triple rated ropes, you'll see that a rope that passes the half test with a bit of margin also always passes the twin test. 3 years old (both 9,2mm Edelrid Topaz Pro Dry) Add a Comment Sort by: opsopcopolis Never let got of your brake hand! Rope is free because Jul is blocked by carbiner. I climbing mostly at the gym but my target is outdoor, I just got lead verified and am looking to get some gear, I am cost conscious but also completely obsessed with climbing. Anybody have any favorites? To compare durability, a good thing to look at between ropes is the sheath percentage; how much of the rope diameter is made up by the sheath. I currently own a 40m 8. Also, some benefits of dry treated ropes that were already discussed, ie abrasion resistance, are specifically for dry treated sheath ropes which the Helix Dry-Core is not. I use a Rad line for ski mountaineering and love it. But it wasn't a bad rope. Hi all, as the title says I'm in need of new double/twin ropes, my old Sterling Fusion's are dying. 8/water repellant. 9 (35m) Edelrid Boa 9. 8. Rope diameter: little ropes are hard to hold, especially with gloves. Trango ropes really catch and they are hard to give rope in lead. My first rope: Edelrid boa 9. 8. Unfortunately, I find their ropes inferior to Edelrid at higher prices. I just bought my first set of quickdraws (Petzl Djinn). 4. 6. More rope drag, harder falls on smaller weight differences. Mammut has a new line of cheaper "classic" ropes out that might be The Mega and Giga Jul are belay devices that are basically an ATC but with the added bonus of assisted braking (like the Gri Gri). Has any got any experience with the Edelrid Switch Adjust that’d be willing to discuss a few questions about usage? I’m… Edit: also Jul2 covers more rope, so it’s almost impossible to get your skin/hand caught in the device, while with MegaJul it looks like it would be more probable (similar to an ATC) So if you’re not planing to get into multipitch outdoor routes and rappelling very soon I would go with Jul2. prone to twisting, not durable, picked up dirt very quickly. 5 infinity and a Black diamond 9. Considering BD 7. 2 mm will last longer. 1 dry treated Bluewater Icon for ice and mixed cragging (sometimes I use one of my half ropes as a tag line); and a 70m 8. Saw the DMM and Edelrid as good alternatives, jsy wondered if any other gear freak out there has some views on the three / could recomend a durable yet We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Petzl PUR Line 6. i don't think you can go wrong, but i think i'd probably get the edelrid if money was not an issue. Survived 5, 5 day trips to the Red. I have a set of Edelrid Flycatchers 6. ) So obviously I'm not gonna buy some sketchy AliBaba Chinese 10mm static rope But in between say BEAL, Edelrid, Edelweiss, Sterling, etc. Might also be worth looking at their 6mm rope, it has a system that makes it a hyperstatic rope up until a certain force (basically After seeing the rope cut video, really convinced me everyone should be on unicore ropes for a little extra rope safety. 5mm If you’ve used either of these ropes, what’s your impression of them? Durability, longevity We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. 2 Climbing Rope: Best Workhorse Rope. Stronger and more packable than traditional cordelettes. Beal Booster III Golden dry 9. Brand doesn't matter much. But other ropes have the core made water repellent as well and then again the sheath is treated. Primarily, my belayer has complained about lowering speed being harder to regulate with a grigri + ohm. So far its held up great (around 100 pitches with lots of falls) with my only complaint being that I needed to add a middle mark already, but I dont like how thick it feels. The Edelrid pinch is still very new (I don’t think it’s actually publicly available yet, just the demo pieces that some pros have) Given that you are still new to climbing (or at least gear ownership) I’d strongly recommend staying with the more established gear types. Approaches that are longer than fifteen minutes kinda hurt when I have a couple of liters of water, a rope, and other horseshit all riding on a single shoulder strap, so I've always stuck with a pack. Guided on bluewaters and had issues with flat spots so bad the rope would slip through grigris and cinches, sheath separation and creep, and very rapid fuzzing. I've dragged that original harness up and through everything you can imagine and I've just gotten around to replacing itwith another Edelrid Jay. If you are heavier, or you are doing more toproping, a 10 or 10. The Ohm is however quite expensive. 8 and a brand new Mammut 9. Yep, been climbing on the Edelrid Jay since I started climbing 5 years ago. Moved PermanentlyThe document has moved here. edelrid is awesome. g. I would assume the Edelrid would do the same. 7mm (would get it in 35m). 5 is the best all around rope every made in my opinion. 8, bought it brand new in the package in July for $90 on Craigslist and have been using it at the gym 2-3 days per week for the last 4 months. Feb 15, 2024 · The Sterling 7/16in WorkPro Static Rope 11 mm is the best caving rope for us due to having used it many times without ever facing any issues that constantly arise with other ropes. Would love to hear your But it does perform better with Edelrid ropes than some others, so you may need to keep that in mind. Black Diamond 10. 3: Best Bicolor Rope. Rough #s are 60/70m and mid 9s. I've climbed on the Mammut rope. I am in the market for new ropes. 7 mm rope will be advantageous. 5mm ropes, solidly in the half rope territory. blue water is also a good company. The maxim ropes are pretty slick, I dont know if for the price they make up the extra use. 6x). I climbed a couple of times with the edelrid swift protect dry pro 8. 5 workhorse with a mezmerizing pattern. "low elongation" ropes for toprope at most gyms) so people are always surprised at how much they stretch, so you usually want to hold people a bit tight at the base of the climb and when they are climbing right above a ledge. Sometimes only the sheath is treated to make it water repellent. For medium to high weight differences. Hi there, I'm looking to buy a 70m single and I've narrowed down my choices to either the Edelrid Heron 9. 113 votes, 200 comments. He knows the rope had barely been used and there were never large falls taken on it. Look for something on sale, you shouldn't need to spend more than $120 for a 60m. Dry treated given the alpine PNW setting. It's difficult to go and check the ropes out in person so i'm hoping to get some advice here. are they all just "good" and safe? Are there any brands to avoid? I've climbed on a number of different ropes, and I've noticed that different brands do feel a little different--in particular, I climbed on a brand new Sterling 9. Diameter of 9. , one is more resilient to falls whereas the When you switch from 1 rope to 2, you don't double the impact force (common misconception). For rope just buy the cheapest one. 8: Best Single Rope. 9ish-10. Still in OK shape, but I wouldn't buy a non-dry again because it rains every time I'm in Kentucky. This device can connect directly to the harness (or anchor for a top down belay) without a carabiner passing through the two closed loop. 5 mm rope that would pass the UIAA single rope test no problem, but at some point the ability of the human hand to apply braking force becomes the limiting factor. When most people think of ropes, they think Sterling and Petzl. For another, I read a report that said Sterling, Petzl, and a few other companies have all their ropes made at the same factory in China. 5mm. If you're an overhang guy, sheath percent won't matter because your rope wont really be rubbing against the rock. Enjoy yourselves! 60m, close to 10mm. I love my Mammut, but I don’t have any experience with Edelrid ropes. Looking at the Petzl Volta or Mammut Alpine Dry online. But I'd favor durability (fatter) or redundancy (half or twin ropes used properly) if I"m swinging sharp stuff. Thin rope handles nice, but can be surprising to a belayer not used to it. 0: Best Static Rope. The consensus is that your first rope should be cheap and thick. I find when it comes to rope the cost of paying for a quality rope is worth it - personally I recommend sterling or edelrid. Other than that I prefer ropes with bi-patterns. My 7mm search slowly crept up and up until I was looking at 8. Normally take out two 30ms (good to have two ropes on a glacier). 8mm 60m for $140. It's expensive, but nice. It’s light, stays dry, can use it for basically anything since it’s triple rated, packs small. I’ll admit I’ve used a single half rope to simul in easy terrain a bunch. I have used doubles in the past for ice climbing. If it’s strictly for indoor I’d suggest a 40m rope, you don’t need 60m and it’ll just get in your way. 6 mm double dry with a neat bipatern that doesn't get harder to see as your rope gets dirty or the Sterling Helix BiPattern DryXP, a 9. Has some light drawbacks. I'm leaning towards the Beal gully's but I'm… Looking for a 60m or 65m tag line for winter alpine/ice climbing for use with a Beal Opera, largely living in a pack unless needed to bail. sterling also makes a bi-color that is 70m. I’ve narrowed it down to 2 options and now and I wanted to get some people’s anecdotal opinions before I choose one. 4 Sterling Xeros rope that I use for glacier travel (Shuksan, Eldorado, etc) and am hoping that I can cover most bases by adding a thicker/longer rock-specific rope. Following that up slightly in price would be: Black Diamond 9. 9, Sterling Fusion Photon (if they still make it?), and Beal Opera, but open to other suggestions! What do you like and why I've used the GriGri 1 and then the GriGri 2 since it came out. My first rope was an edelrid. I own both; the Edelrid Parrot is my go-to gym rope since it‘s cheap, doesn’t need to be water repellant, is made from recycling ropes and will likely take lots of falls during indoor training. Choosing the right climbing rope As a Sterling Athlete Team member, I have the benefit of having as many as 12 ropes at any given time in my quiver. Definitely <$150, hopefully closer to $100 if you catch a fire sale. Alternatives to the Edelrid Ohm assisted braking device? My wife and I have been testing out the Ohm in the gym. 1. There are a few annoyances with it concerning rope management but I think you can get the hang of it when both partners used it a few times. What is not often discussed is the belay of climbers lighter Oct 3, 2012 · Need a new single rope planning on getting the 9. He said they could build a ~6. The other option would be mammut alpine dry 8mm (pro: cheaper, perf Depending on what you're doing, the Edelrid TC Eco Dry is arguably the best rope money can buy. Does anyone have one they really like? What features are helpful? Aside from the issue with twin and half ropes, I suggest caution on thin rope for your first rope. Dec 30, 2017 · I'm having a hard time choosing between the Mammut Infinity Protect, Sterling Velocity, and the Edelrid Boa. There's a decent deal on the mammut crag classic but i'm torn between the 9. Find a single, dynamic rope. Cheap is key. 8 Edelrid Pika (60M). Any opinions on which I should go with. Of course, of all of these brakes, the MPD is the super-star. 4 mm dry treated Bluewater Excellence 70m for ice and alpine mixed climbing; a 70m 9. The weight difference recommendations at the end are for short climbs with minimal rope drag, as you would find in a gym. Lots of good brands, Mammut makes great ropes, Petzl, Edelrid, Beal, I would never buy climbing ropes at full-price, if you wait and search enough you'll always find really good deals. For Getting a 60m rope for < $100 is a great deal, so the edelrid flashlight II or the beal yuji at the link I provided would be fine. Let's talk about rope bags! I've never had a rope bag before (I always just coiled my rope and flaked it onto a normal tarp). At your price point, you really don't have to stress that hard because there aren't too many options. Sterling Velocity XEROS 9. Pick whichever one you can get cheaper. This rope retains its suppleness even with intensive use and many wet-dry cycles. And yes we are scared of falling. I have the 70m Edelrid Boa Eco 9. Maxim, Mammut, BD, Sterling, Bluewater are all solid brands. Or those Tendon ropes at MEC if you're in Canada. I’ve done loads of comparing and researching and I’ve figured out what I’m looking for in my next rope. 5 and the 9. Share Add a Comment Sort by: Top Open comment sort options Best New Controversial Old Q&A [deleted] • Comment deleted by user Reply reply poorboychevelle • We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Made in the USA. The next thing I started to look at was belay device (ATC) rope limitations. Edelweiss Oxygen II SuperEverDry 8. I know this is a luxury most don&rsquo;t have, unless you are a Mountain Guide. With a small diameter, the PINTAIL LITE is geared especially toward anyone who likes to travel light and flexibly. You can look up reviews for them elsewhere if you are curious, but truly for your first rope, you just need the basics. I'm looking to buy my first indoor rope. 3. If your budget only allows for one, two or even three, I have a few tips on rope choice that may help you choose. worked long enough and i liked it MUCH better than the Sterling i had before it You should choose your rope diameter based on your climbing preferences (lead vs TR, Trad, Gym, Ice?) and your size. 4M subscribers in the climbing community. I am in the market for half/twin ropes. But I also use a cheaper beal rope for indoor and can’t complain too much (it does get twisted easily) New rope suggestions? Hey there. Generally a thicker sheath means a more durable rope. Has anyone on here used the edelrid fuse/megawatt? If so how do they stand up to the rig/asap? Archived post. Small: 15 kg Medium: 25kg High: more than 30kg of difference. I contacted Edelrid about it and their reply is that there is no issue with the device as according to them "you shouldn't ever let go from the dead end of the rope" and if you use their very specific carabiners the device will perform adequately. 5mm Mammutt, specifically as my girlfriend is just getting into climbing and is not confident with doubles, and struggles to use my 10. I'm planning on either getting doubles or a light single + Petzl Pur Line. Do you mean like how you would belay with a grigri with your break hand holding the rope and on the cam? I'm planning to use this for lead belaying both indoors and outdoors (only sport climbing for now) - is there a reason why you're looking to switch from Mega to Giga Jul? Hello r/climbing , I am a indoor boulderer (but have also bouldered outdoors - just rooutinely go to the gym) that wants to delve into the outdoors more! I have had some top-roping classes to get some proper instruction on belaying and top-rope climbing and have top-roped/belayed both on real rock and routinely indoors for the past three months or so (hardest grades: indoor 6b+, outdoors 6a 2nd thing is that your rope will stretch a lot more since its dynamic (vs. RAD line could be used for glacier travel (a bit If you asked the manufacturer they would say absolutely not due to obvious liability, however if you understand the risks then you can make your own decision. 5mm min. All Sterling Ropes come with a dry core which mainly just helps with durability. 5 kN as a half and 8. I don't know what it exactly means for Sterling ropes, but, there are multiple rope treatment "levels". I don't know of any crazy discounts currently. Others are welcome to post and ask questions about our industry if interested. I… See full list on switchbacktravel. See here [1] on the Edelrid website the description of their "Pro Dry" treatment. I'm looking to get a new rope, and I'm thinking it should have its own rope bag. Looking at the Purline, RAD line. The device only works properly with very specific carabiners, with very specific rope thicknesses, and very specific rope conditions ( too new in wont lock, too old and the device becomes to grippy to belay without using strength to move the rope. 6 Best two ropes I've ever used, period. I've only really ever used Edelrid ropes and they have treated me well. Mammut Infinity 9. Even though the 60m I almost always used it at smith which destroys ropes. For example, the Beal Opera has a peak force of 5. I have the mammut workhorse 9. com. Your suggested rope looks good for rock climbing and is surely rated for ice and whatnot. Does the brand of static rope really matter or are they all great? (ie. 387 votes, 343 comments. The 5. 7 (pro: light, cons: too thin? can't find a ton of reviews). I use it regularly. Welcome to the Rope Access subreddit! This is a subreddit so that those of us in the industry can share experiences, photos, job openings and various information in regards to our Rope Access careers. You will find better and more knowledgeable support for the grigri especially in the near future. Definitely solves the weight difference problem reliably. It may be worth looking into one of the Edelrid unicore ropes. 60m or 70m in length. 9 triple rated rope, and I liked it so much that I will buy myself for the upcoming season. 2mm (pro: Aramid sheath, cons: heavy, expensive) and petzl paso guide 7. Does anyone know why the Sterling here is cheaper than the Edelrid while offering the Dry-core feature? I'm comparing both ropes in the 40m model. 9 for my heavy abuse rope. If you weigh 160 lbs, and do mostly sport lead, a 9. 2 is good for a newer climber/belayer. Edelrid is a brand many climbers don't focus on. Toothless… Moved PermanentlyThe document has moved here. Nov 14, 2022 · Edelrid Swift Eco Dry 8. The cheapest I could find from a reputable brand was this Tendon 9. 8 kN as a twin (1. Sterling Helix Dry-Core rope is NOT fully dry treated, DryXP is their fully dry treatment. It kept me alive. In that same thought, a thicker rope will be more durable than a thinner rope. 9 gym rope at 40m vs a Beal Booster III or Edelrid Boa in 60m. Edelrid Spoc – Climbers' Experiences and Recommendations? Hey fellow climbers! I'm in the midst of deciding between two lightweight progress capture devices: the Petzl Nano Traxion and the Edelrid Spoc. Very robust canyoning rope with twisted polyester sheath for maximum abrasion resistance. All that said I I would look at sheath percentage if you can find it, that gives you a great idea of how abrasion resistant it is. PINCH Basic Functions | EDELRID A new Grigri like device from Edelrid with an interesting extra feature or two, but one in particular that makes me nervous. 7. 9: Best Triple-Rated Rope. Edelrid make a specific figure of 8 for ultrathin ropes that works perfectly with the radline and makes rappelling on a single strand quite easy. But what I find far more important to a good brake in a pulley system is not the brake itself, but The thicker you make the rope, the more sheath and core you have, and generally speaking, a longer-lasting rope overall, though the manufacturers can play with sheath thickness (and corresponding core thickness) to make a rope with the same thickness that is more resilient in certain aspects (e. I wouldn't hesitate to grab either of the ropes you linked. Any suggestions? Lightweight, good dry treatment, and durability are my prioritized attributes. We're both very happy with how it works, as there is a big weight difference between us, and it makes it easier for her to both catch me when I fall and to let me down in a controlled manner. Edelrid Tommy Caldwell Eco Dry ColorTec 9. I own a couple of opera Beal 8. Just wondering if anyone has any experience or thoughts on the above ropes? Thanks. Fed through gri2 fine. The abundance of ropes on the market and the many Edelrid is also now manufacturing their ropes with their own version of unicore now IIRC, which is an important factor to me (increased cut resistance). I will be in the market for a new rope in the next few months, currently I have a 9. BEAL, Sterling, etc. 27 votes, 56 comments. (ive owned edelrid, mammut, sterling, petzl, metolius, black diamond) We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. So a friend of mine inherited a climbing rope (11 mm) from New England Ropes. I’ve only used Edelrid and Sterling but I feel like Edelrid doesn’t get as twisted and was easier to use right out of the packaging (you pull the rope through the packaging whereas with Sterling I had to go through this whole process of pulling it through a carabiner). Learn more at SterlingRope. com Apr 4, 2025 · We tested 13 climbing ropes from Sterling, Petzl, Edelrid, Mammut, and others to find the best options for you. The 2 biggest things to keep in mind are that thin ropes cut more easily on edges, and half/twin ropes stretch much more, which can result in decking on a Petzl Nano Traxion vs. Jun 6, 2025 · We took to the whips to find the best climbing ropes for every type of climbing, with top picks from Sterling, Mammut, and Edelrid. The way I use these is to always have one hand around the rope and on the device while the other gives and takes slack. Now, you can also use this device to rappel without a prusik. My previous rope was also an Edelrid - it was a 10mm 60M as well. It can occasionally cause trouble if you high clip, where once you climb up to the clip after high slipping, the slack introduced by your ascent doesn't feed back through the ohm, so if your belayer isn't watching the . 8mm (40m) - Could consider the jump to the Boa Gym if it's worth it Beal Virus Sep 26, 2016 · Find rock climbing routes, photos, and guides for every state, along with experiences and advice from fellow climbers. 9mm 60m twin ropes for soloing; a set of 8. It does seems like the current weaknesses of ropes are weight (who wouldn't want a lighter one if no other trade offs ?), and cut resistance. 9 Edelrid Swift non-dry for alpine rock. I currently see 6 ways the cut resistance issue is dealt with : the sheath : not existing on firsts ropes, some have more, more material to be Are there any fall arrest devices for ropes less than ⌀10mm? ASAP, Goblin, Quantum, RED, etc, are more or less all ~⌀10. Am interested in what others are liking Both ropes look pretty comparable. At a minimum I think I will need a rope and a rope bag, my main question is should I get a 60m vs a 35/40m rope? Considering the BD 9. I've also used the Eddy, Petzl RIG, Petzl I'D large and small Ø, Petzl Stop, CT Sparrow, Faders SUM, MPD, Cobra, LC rope brake, and several of my own home-made brakes. Purline is significantly cheaper but single use, and I'm weary of how it will perform in winter conditions. I'll be using the rope as an all rounder for sport climbing, usually just on sights / red points, with occasional top roping. It handles Good ropes if you want a burly rope that's going to last but be nicer that has all of these things include the Edelrid Tommy Caldwell Pro Dry DT, a 9. 7mm Mammut Crag Dry rope 9. At that point, having a rope bag doesn't make sense -- using a tarp and strapping the rope to the top of a pack is easier. For outdoors (mostly Germany and Mediterranean sea cragsI have the OPs mention: sterling velocity evolution in 9. I've climbed on a ton of different ropes both indoors and out, but I would be lying if I said I knew a damn thing about them. Adding to this, Both my static cord and climbing rope from Edelweiss have only lasted a season vs my Edelrid gear that's still in good shape for 3 years. I'm not a trad dad, but to me this seems a little bit scary; I can't quite put my finger on it but I absolutely prefer to instead use it as a normal ATC and with a prusik. It handles really nicely in belay devices and clips smoothly. And a 'slip' and catch, that leads to a jerk on super-statics like RADline can cause anchors to fail. For this reason, I decided that I would rather go with two rope raps, which can actually speed things up if simul-rapping. It was stored in an attic and we wanted to determine the rope age to see if it would be safe for climbing. The only dud ropes I've encountered are blue water and edelrid. I've read every thread, I swear. 5mm wall rope as it is seriously well used and furry. I've had fantastic luck with a Mammut 9. I once read (long ago, so sorry no link) an interview with an engineer fron Edelrid. Dry-treated ropes for outdoors if you plan to climb in wet conditions. Its neon-yellow color scheme ensures good visibility at all times. How do you determine this age? If older than ~5 years old but in great condition, would you lead on it? top-rope? I have an Edelrid Python rope and a friend with an Edelrid Ibex, both are fantastic ropes, handle beautifully and have excellent dynamic. kjuzkprl ktdy nrwgv nehcbyzk yqjbx obkac qkxqlsyd fzjv hbuklp pwopg